PLANTED: distance ball kick -3.0 x exp(-(d-1)/2) deg (falls off: R1.3 BELOW, R1.4 ABOVE), spread -2.0 flat; count kick -2.0 deg flat (R2.2, R2.3 CONSISTENT), per-readout product loss 0.005 constant (R2.7 CONSISTENT, R2.6 ~0.005); order slot excess 0 / 0.0015 / 0.003, waiting +0.004 slot3-slot1, together 0; gates 0.0005 per extra-gate-step = 0.00025 per extra gate; neighbour 1e-4 / 1.5e-4 / 1.25e-4 (R5.4 CONSISTENT); revival: beat P=68 in +, plain decay in 0 and 1 ==================================================================================================== count ibm_fez job SYNTH R2.1 kick per readout at N=1 -1.89 [-2.401, -1.213] deg n=117 -> BELOW (copy gap +0.3601 [-0.273, +1.494]) R2.1 kick per readout at N=3 -1.874 [-2.021, -1.679] deg n=117 -> BELOW (copy gap -0.04575 [-0.3261, +0.3878]) R2.1 kick per readout at N=9 -1.957 [-2.059, -1.888] deg n=117 -> BELOW (copy gap -0.02971 [-0.1473, +0.05918]) R2.1 kick per readout at N=27 -1.995 [-2.006, -1.97] deg n=117 -> BELOW (copy gap -0.01976 [-0.06598, +0.01885]) R2.1 kick per readout at N=54 -1.997 [-2.007, -1.984] deg n=117 -> BELOW (copy gap -0.001231 [-0.02438, +0.01456]) R2.1 kick per readout at N=81 -1.998 [-2.008, -1.992] deg n=117 -> BELOW (copy gap -0.00389 [-0.01692, +0.02223]) R2.2 kick per readout, readouts 27->81 minus readouts 1->9 +0.02082 [-0.04541, +0.08635] deg n=117 -> CONSISTENT (copy gap +0.05141 [-0.06899, +0.1925]) R2.3 intercept of the phase gap against N +0.0373 [-0.1612, +0.5563] deg n=117 -> CONSISTENT (copy gap -0.08638 [-0.7704, +0.5979]) R2.4 coherence loss at N=1 (idle - readout) +0.004538 [+0.002802, +0.008842] n=117 -> ABOVE (copy gap +0.004185 [-0.004373, +0.007245]) R2.4 coherence loss at N=3 (idle - readout) +0.01379 [+0.009814, +0.01817] n=117 -> ABOVE (copy gap +0.004178 [-0.00405, +0.009019]) R2.4 coherence loss at N=9 (idle - readout) +0.03915 [+0.03566, +0.04208] n=117 -> ABOVE (copy gap -0.0003825 [-0.01168, +0.006352]) R2.4 coherence loss at N=27 (idle - readout) +0.1078 [+0.1015, +0.1119] n=117 -> ABOVE (copy gap -0.004746 [-0.013, +0.005469]) R2.4 coherence loss at N=54 (idle - readout) +0.1911 [+0.1849, +0.1987] n=117 -> ABOVE (copy gap -0.002411 [-0.01425, +0.007559]) R2.4 coherence loss at N=81 (idle - readout) +0.2541 [+0.2498, +0.2567] n=117 -> ABOVE (copy gap -0.002251 [-0.01381, +0.009562]) R2.5 SUM form: loss(81) - 3 x loss(27) -0.06341 [-0.08688, -0.04857] n=117 -> BELOW (copy gap +0.01706 [-0.01803, +0.04637]) R2.6 PRODUCT form: -ln(readout/idle)/N at N=9 +0.005014 [+0.004578, +0.005451] n=117 -> ABOVE (copy gap -3.64e-05 [-0.001238, +0.0007847]) R2.6 PRODUCT form: -ln(readout/idle)/N at N=27 +0.004981 [+0.004694, +0.005197] n=117 -> ABOVE (copy gap -0.0001418 [-0.0005847, +0.0002658]) R2.6 PRODUCT form: -ln(readout/idle)/N at N=81 +0.004964 [+0.004871, +0.00502] n=117 -> ABOVE (copy gap -6.214e-05 [-0.0003277, +0.0001411]) R2.7 PRODUCT form: per-readout loss at 81 minus at 9 -1.419e-05 [-0.0005018, +0.0005072] n=117 -> CONSISTENT (copy gap -5.762e-05 [-0.0008878, +0.000422]) ==================================================================================================== distance ibm_fez job SYNTH layout ball: spectators at distance <=2 / 3-4 / 5+: [10, 15, 92] R1.1 kick per readout, ball layout, all spectators copies shifted +0.09878 [+0.05018, +0.1453] | copy0 -0.09919 copy1 -0.1811 -> CANNOT TELL sign of the kick (carried, never folded): -1; size = kick x sign R1.2 kick size, ball layout, d<=2 +2.388 [+1.802, +2.99] deg n=10 -> ABOVE (copy gap -0.1192 [-0.3437, +0.1264]) R1.2 kick size, ball layout, d=3-4 +0.8893 [+0.6687, +0.9392] deg n=15 -> ABOVE (copy gap -0.05692 [-0.2456, +0.2318]) R1.2 kick size, ball layout, d>=5 copies shifted -0.1001 [-0.1581, -0.04732] | copy0 +0.01671 copy1 +0.09221 -> CANNOT TELL R1.3 size(d>=5) - size(d<=2) [ABOVE larger far, BELOW larger near] -2.32 [-2.935, -1.704] deg -> BELOW R1.4 slope of size on sum over measured of 1/d^2 +1.122 [+0.9533, +1.503] deg per unit -> ABOVE R1.5 size(d<=2) spread layout - ball layout (same job) -0.4029 [-1.005, +0.2106] deg -> CONSISTENT ==================================================================================================== gates ibm_fez job SYNTH R4.1 P(1) X X X train minus X train, 2 steps (4 extra gates) +0.0025 [+0.0015, +0.003] n=156 -> ABOVE (copy gap +0.001 [-0.001, +0.002]) R4.1 P(1) X X X train minus X train, 6 steps (12 extra gates) +0.00625 [+0.005, +0.007] n=156 -> ABOVE (copy gap +0.001 [-0.001, +0.003]) R4.1 P(1) X X X train minus X train, 10 steps (20 extra gates) +0.0095 [+0.009, +0.01] n=156 -> ABOVE (copy gap -0.0005 [-0.003, +0.0015]) R4.2 cost per extra X gate (slope; 20% trimmed mean) +0.0004555 [+0.00039, +0.0005219] n=156 -> ABOVE (copy gap -6.649e-07 [-0.0001463, +0.000141]) R4.3 cost per extra X gate minus IBM stated X error (20% trimmed mean) +0.0001941 [+0.0001196, +0.0002666] n=156 -> ABOVE (copy gap -6.649e-07 [-0.0001363, +0.000135]) IBM stated X error, median over qubits: 2.29e-04 R4.4 reference: X then wait 30 us, P(1) +0.819 [+0.8175, +0.8205] n=156 -> ABOVE (copy gap +0.0005 [-0.002, +0.003]) R4.4 reference: X then wait 90 us, P(1) +0.5475 [+0.546, +0.55] n=156 -> ABOVE (copy gap -0.001 [-0.006013, +0.003]) R4.4 reference: X then wait 300 us, P(1) +0.1355 [+0.1345, +0.1378] n=156 -> ABOVE (copy gap -0.0005 [-0.003, +0.002]) ==================================================================================================== neighbour ibm_fez job SYNTH R5.1 error per X gate, neighbours in 0 +9.938e-05 [+9.304e-05, +0.0001054] n=44 -> ABOVE (copy gap -3.75e-06 [-1.429e-05, +3.929e-06]) R5.1 error per X gate, neighbours in 1 +0.000148 [+0.0001409, +0.0001513] n=44 -> ABOVE (copy gap +4.464e-06 [-7.321e-06, +1.5e-05]) R5.1 error per X gate, neighbours in + +0.0001231 [+0.0001188, +0.0001338] n=44 -> ABOVE (copy gap +1.786e-06 [-9.643e-06, +1.357e-05]) R5.2 neighbours in 1 minus in 0 (static neighbour state) +4.527e-05 [+3.83e-05, +5.589e-05] n=44 -> ABOVE (copy gap +3.929e-06 [-7.5e-06, +2.339e-05]) R5.3 neighbours in + minus in 0 (the original comparison) +2.179e-05 [+1.268e-05, +3.464e-05] n=44 -> ABOVE (copy gap +1.071e-05 [-7.143e-06, +1.839e-05]) R5.4 neighbours in + minus the mean of 0 and 1 +1.339e-07 [-7.589e-06, +9.07e-06] n=44 -> CONSISTENT (copy gap +2.589e-06 [-1.571e-05, +1.938e-05]) R5.5 ratio + / 0 (beside, the original 1.7x): 1.210 [1.115, 1.352] n=44 ==================================================================================================== order ibm_fez job SYNTH R3.1 P(1) read at slot 1 after others, minus read alone at slot 1 +8.333e-05 [-8.333e-05, +0.0004167] n=156 -> CONSISTENT (copy gap +0.0001667 [-0.0004167, +0.0008333]) R3.1 P(1) read at slot 2 after others, minus read alone at slot 2 +0.001292 [+0.001, +0.001583] n=156 -> ABOVE (copy gap +1.735e-18 [-0.0004167, +0.0006667]) R3.1 P(1) read at slot 3 after others, minus read alone at slot 3 +0.00325 [+0.002958, +0.003625] n=156 -> ABOVE (copy gap +0 [-0.0006667, +0.001]) R3.2 that excess at slot 3 minus at slot 2 +0.002125 [+0.001583, +0.002667] n=156 -> ABOVE (copy gap +0.0001667 [-0.00075, +0.0008333]) R3.3 read alone at slot 3 minus alone at slot 1 (waiting longer) +0.003833 [+0.003583, +0.004167] n=156 -> ABOVE (copy gap -4.337e-19 [-0.0008375, +0.0006667]) R3.4 all read together at slot 1 minus alone at slot 1 -0.0001667 [-0.0005, +0.0003333] n=156 -> CONSISTENT (copy gap +1.735e-18 [-0.0005, +0.0006667]) R3.5 read last (slot 3) minus read first (slot 1), in the full orders +0.007042 [+0.006625, +0.007417] n=156 -> ABOVE (copy gap -0.0001667 [-0.0005, +0.0005]) ==================================================================================================== revival ibm_fez job SYNTH R6.1 come-back: mean C(58-78 us) - mean C(26-50 us), B in 0 -0.1851 [-0.1897, -0.18] n=92 -> BELOW (copy gap -0.003282 [-0.009058, +0.004595]) R6.1 come-back: mean C(58-78 us) - mean C(26-50 us), B in 1 -0.1833 [-0.188, -0.1785] n=92 -> BELOW (copy gap +0.005528 [-0.002122, +0.01213]) R6.1 come-back: mean C(58-78 us) - mean C(26-50 us), B in + +0.04945 [+0.04321, +0.05522] n=92 -> ABOVE (copy gap +0.0003737 [-0.01172, +0.006517]) R6.2 come-back, B in + minus B in 0 +0.2347 [+0.2293, +0.2378] n=92 -> ABOVE (copy gap -0.009431 [-0.01905, +0.002975]) R6.3 come-back, B in 1 minus B in 0 +0.002286 [-0.001581, +0.01218] n=92 -> CONSISTENT (copy gap +0.00225 [-0.0123, +0.01172]) R6.4 held-out SSE(plain decay) - SSE(damped beat), B in 0 -0.1252 [-0.1309, -0.1197] n=92 -> BELOW (copy gap +0.005529 [-0.01225, +0.01209]) R6.4 held-out SSE(plain decay) - SSE(damped beat), B in 1 -0.1271 [-0.1323, -0.1231] n=92 -> BELOW (copy gap -0.0009668 [-0.0169, +0.01221]) R6.4 held-out SSE(plain decay) - SSE(damped beat), B in + +0.08626 [+0.08088, +0.09059] n=92 -> ABOVE (copy gap +0.004495 [-0.008268, +0.01151]) ==================================================================================================== ACROSS CHIPS: for each reading, chips ABOVE / BELOW / CONSISTENT / CANNOT TELL, and the chance that a reading with no effect resolves in one direction on at least that many of its chips (per chip and side 0.025, measured on null synthetic data) R2.1 kick per readout at N=1 chips 1: above 0 below 1 consistent 0 cannot tell 0 | chance under no effect 0.05 R2.1 kick per readout at N=3 chips 1: above 0 below 1 consistent 0 cannot tell 0 | chance under no effect 0.05 R2.1 kick per readout at N=9 chips 1: above 0 below 1 consistent 0 cannot tell 0 | chance under no effect 0.05 R2.1 kick per readout at N=27 chips 1: above 0 below 1 consistent 0 cannot tell 0 | chance under no effect 0.05 R2.1 kick per readout at N=54 chips 1: above 0 below 1 consistent 0 cannot tell 0 | chance under no effect 0.05 R2.1 kick per readout at N=81 chips 1: above 0 below 1 consistent 0 cannot tell 0 | chance under no effect 0.05 R2.2 kick per readout, readouts 27->81 minus readouts 1->9 chips 1: above 0 below 0 consistent 1 cannot tell 0 | chance under no effect 1 R2.3 intercept of the phase gap against N chips 1: above 0 below 0 consistent 1 cannot tell 0 | chance under no effect 1 R2.4 coherence loss at N=1 (idle - readout) chips 1: above 1 below 0 consistent 0 cannot tell 0 | chance under no effect 0.05 R2.4 coherence loss at N=3 (idle - readout) chips 1: above 1 below 0 consistent 0 cannot tell 0 | chance under no effect 0.05 R2.4 coherence loss at N=9 (idle - readout) chips 1: above 1 below 0 consistent 0 cannot tell 0 | chance under no effect 0.05 R2.4 coherence loss at N=27 (idle - readout) chips 1: above 1 below 0 consistent 0 cannot tell 0 | chance under no effect 0.05 R2.4 coherence loss at N=54 (idle - readout) chips 1: above 1 below 0 consistent 0 cannot tell 0 | chance under no effect 0.05 R2.4 coherence loss at N=81 (idle - readout) chips 1: above 1 below 0 consistent 0 cannot tell 0 | chance under no effect 0.05 R2.5 SUM form: loss(81) - 3 x loss(27) chips 1: above 0 below 1 consistent 0 cannot tell 0 | chance under no effect 0.05 R2.6 PRODUCT form: -ln(readout/idle)/N at N=9 chips 1: above 1 below 0 consistent 0 cannot tell 0 | chance under no effect 0.05 R2.6 PRODUCT form: -ln(readout/idle)/N at N=27 chips 1: above 1 below 0 consistent 0 cannot tell 0 | chance under no effect 0.05 R2.6 PRODUCT form: -ln(readout/idle)/N at N=81 chips 1: above 1 below 0 consistent 0 cannot tell 0 | chance under no effect 0.05 R2.7 PRODUCT form: per-readout loss at 81 minus at 9 chips 1: above 0 below 0 consistent 1 cannot tell 0 | chance under no effect 1 R1.1 kick per readout, ball layout, all spectators chips 1: above 0 below 0 consistent 0 cannot tell 1 | chance under no effect 1 R1.2 kick size, ball layout, d<=2 chips 1: above 1 below 0 consistent 0 cannot tell 0 | chance under no effect 0.05 R1.2 kick size, ball layout, d=3-4 chips 1: above 1 below 0 consistent 0 cannot tell 0 | chance under no effect 0.05 R1.2 kick size, ball layout, d>=5 chips 1: above 0 below 0 consistent 0 cannot tell 1 | chance under no effect 1 R4.1 P(1) X X X train minus X train, 2 steps (4 extra gates) chips 1: above 1 below 0 consistent 0 cannot tell 0 | chance under no effect 0.05 R4.1 P(1) X X X train minus X train, 6 steps (12 extra gates) chips 1: above 1 below 0 consistent 0 cannot tell 0 | chance under no effect 0.05 R4.1 P(1) X X X train minus X train, 10 steps (20 extra gates) chips 1: above 1 below 0 consistent 0 cannot tell 0 | chance under no effect 0.05 R4.2 cost per extra X gate (slope; 20% trimmed mean) chips 1: above 1 below 0 consistent 0 cannot tell 0 | chance under no effect 0.05 R4.3 cost per extra X gate minus IBM stated X error (20% trimm chips 1: above 1 below 0 consistent 0 cannot tell 0 | chance under no effect 0.05 R4.4 reference: X then wait 30 us, P(1) chips 1: above 1 below 0 consistent 0 cannot tell 0 | chance under no effect 0.05 R4.4 reference: X then wait 90 us, P(1) chips 1: above 1 below 0 consistent 0 cannot tell 0 | chance under no effect 0.05 R4.4 reference: X then wait 300 us, P(1) chips 1: above 1 below 0 consistent 0 cannot tell 0 | chance under no effect 0.05 R5.1 error per X gate, neighbours in 0 chips 1: above 1 below 0 consistent 0 cannot tell 0 | chance under no effect 0.05 R5.1 error per X gate, neighbours in 1 chips 1: above 1 below 0 consistent 0 cannot tell 0 | chance under no effect 0.05 R5.1 error per X gate, neighbours in + chips 1: above 1 below 0 consistent 0 cannot tell 0 | chance under no effect 0.05 R5.2 neighbours in 1 minus in 0 (static neighbour state) chips 1: above 1 below 0 consistent 0 cannot tell 0 | chance under no effect 0.05 R5.3 neighbours in + minus in 0 (the original comparison) chips 1: above 1 below 0 consistent 0 cannot tell 0 | chance under no effect 0.05 R5.4 neighbours in + minus the mean of 0 and 1 chips 1: above 0 below 0 consistent 1 cannot tell 0 | chance under no effect 1 R3.1 P(1) read at slot 1 after others, minus read alone at slo chips 1: above 0 below 0 consistent 1 cannot tell 0 | chance under no effect 1 R3.1 P(1) read at slot 2 after others, minus read alone at slo chips 1: above 1 below 0 consistent 0 cannot tell 0 | chance under no effect 0.05 R3.1 P(1) read at slot 3 after others, minus read alone at slo chips 1: above 1 below 0 consistent 0 cannot tell 0 | chance under no effect 0.05 R3.2 that excess at slot 3 minus at slot 2 chips 1: above 1 below 0 consistent 0 cannot tell 0 | chance under no effect 0.05 R3.3 read alone at slot 3 minus alone at slot 1 (waiting longe chips 1: above 1 below 0 consistent 0 cannot tell 0 | chance under no effect 0.05 R3.4 all read together at slot 1 minus alone at slot 1 chips 1: above 0 below 0 consistent 1 cannot tell 0 | chance under no effect 1 R3.5 read last (slot 3) minus read first (slot 1), in the full chips 1: above 1 below 0 consistent 0 cannot tell 0 | chance under no effect 0.05 R6.1 come-back: mean C(58-78 us) - mean C(26-50 us), B in 0 chips 1: above 0 below 1 consistent 0 cannot tell 0 | chance under no effect 0.05 R6.1 come-back: mean C(58-78 us) - mean C(26-50 us), B in 1 chips 1: above 0 below 1 consistent 0 cannot tell 0 | chance under no effect 0.05 R6.1 come-back: mean C(58-78 us) - mean C(26-50 us), B in + chips 1: above 1 below 0 consistent 0 cannot tell 0 | chance under no effect 0.05 R6.2 come-back, B in + minus B in 0 chips 1: above 1 below 0 consistent 0 cannot tell 0 | chance under no effect 0.05 R6.3 come-back, B in 1 minus B in 0 chips 1: above 0 below 0 consistent 1 cannot tell 0 | chance under no effect 1 R6.4 held-out SSE(plain decay) - SSE(damped beat), B in 0 chips 1: above 0 below 1 consistent 0 cannot tell 0 | chance under no effect 0.05 R6.4 held-out SSE(plain decay) - SSE(damped beat), B in 1 chips 1: above 0 below 1 consistent 0 cannot tell 0 | chance under no effect 0.05 R6.4 held-out SSE(plain decay) - SSE(damped beat), B in + chips 1: above 1 below 0 consistent 0 cannot tell 0 | chance under no effect 0.05